Probiotics Home | Certified Organic Probiotic Formula |  Ten FREE Cancer Reports

Probiotic bacteria health boon

Gut-friendly bugs don't have to be alive to boost immune system.
03 February 2004

Nature News Service / Macmillan Magazines Ltd 2004


Television advertisements are filled with advice about the benefit of foods containing 'friendly' bacteria, such as probiotic yoghurt. But a US-led research team now says that you don't need live bacteria to boost your digestive system just their DNA.

If true, that should allow the health effects of these bacteria to be incorporated into a range of different types of foods, or even pills and injections. Live bacteria are generally restricted to products such as dairy foods, because cooking or heating the cultures kills them.

The average human gut contains about 100 different species of bacteria, including 'good' bacteria, such as Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterium, which aid digestion, bolster the immune system and battle for space with 'bad' bacteria, such as those that cause food poisoning. Some of these beneficial bacteria are added to products such as live-culture yoghurt. Probiotic foods and supplements are big business the worldwide market is worth around US$6 billion a year.

Eyal Raz of the University of California, San Diego, and his colleagues looked at the effect of these bacteria on mice with colitis, a condition similar to inflammatory bowel disease in humans. Surprisingly, they found that the bacteria were just as effective when inactivated with gamma-ray radiation as when live cultures were used1.

A similar health effect occurred when Raz and colleagues treated the mice with a synthetic DNA molecule known as an immunostimulatory oligonucleotide, which mimics the effect of the bacteria on the immune system. "This shows that it's the bacterial DNA that gives the benefit," says Raz.

If the oligonucleotide can be added to food, it may expand the range of probiotic products, says Raz. "Live probiotics are not the best way to deliver the DNA," he adds. "The food starts to ferment. If you add live bacteria to orange juice, you get a different taste every hour."

DNA that boosts the immune system could even be given by pill or injection, Raz suggests. "You can't do this with bacteria," he points out.

It's an interesting proposal, says Glenn Gibson, who studies gut bacteria at the University of Reading, UK. But he says that probiotic foods have a raft of other benefits that rely on using live bacteria. They need to reproduce if they are to crowd out harmful strains and combat food poisoning, for example.

"I'm sure probiotics manufacturers would be delighted if they thought they could put it all in a pill," says Gibson. "It would be cheaper and the shelf-life would be a lot longer. But they usually need to be alive immune stimulation is the exception."

Gibson suggests that food researchers searching for healthy food additives should turn to 'prebiotics' compounds that alter the gut's balance by boosting the growth of friendly bacteria that are already present inside the body.

  1. Rachmilewitz, D. et al. Toll-like receptor 9 signaling mediates the anti-inflammatory effects of probiotics in murine experimental colitis. Gastroenterology, 126, 520 - 528(2004). |Article|

Reported in Nature News Service / Macmillan Magazines Ltd 2004

Health-Report Comment

Dead bacteria may give health benefits through the DNA of the dead bacteria. However, this is purely speculation by medical researchers at this stage. All indications are for a probiotic formula to be highly effective, it is best to for it to contain "live" bacteria rather than dead bacteria. I fail to see how "good"  bacteria when they are dead, could be anywhere near as beneficial to the body as when they are alive.

As always, do your homework first before choosing a probiotic formula. Read all you can about it. If possible speak to people who have first hand knowledge by using the good bacteria formula. If you don't get results from a probiotic formula that you would expect, it could well be the bacteria are dead and no where near as effective as a properly formulated live probiotic culture.

Not only should the probiotics deliver millions of bacteria into the alimentary canal, but the formula should be based on a proven nutritional foundation. This way the body has a very good chance of assimilating the nutrients in the formula along with better assimilation for the food.

Geoff Goldie

Hit Counter